Baltimore
- psychotropics in children and buprenorphine in pharmacies
From Washington
DC (DC) I travelled by train to a snowing Baltimore on Monday
6th January to give a seminar on our recently published international
and Australian analyses of psychostimulants.
My hosts in the School of Pharmacy were Dr Julie Zito the US expert
on psychotropics prescribing in US children, Tony Tommassello
(Ph D) a friend from 1998 who had won a $US 0.5million grant to
study buprenorphine uptake in city settings and Dr Ed Johnson
former pharmacy director and buprenorphine expert formerly at
Johns Hopkins University .
Dr Zito reported over 10% of students in east coast regions were
taking prescribed psychostimulants compared to NSW's 2-4%.
Dr Zito pointed to doubled or more use to the levels taken by
20-45 year olds of antidepressants , psychostimulants and other
psychotropic drugs in US children down to toddlers .
The FDA estimates 70-80% of these drugs are used for unapproved
indications and now requires full paediatric information on dosage
and adverse effects in drug packages.
MRI brain scans are used to monitor effects in children (Table
2, Reference 1).
Drs Johnson and Tommasello will train and study pharmacists' buprenorphine
dosing of opioid dependents after decades of being excluded from
methadone maintenance
Washington
DC - the active APhA in DC and ASHP seminar in Bethesda
On Tuesday 7th January I gave a morning and an afternoon seminar
on our initial results of the National Pharmacy Database Project
(NPDP).
In Bethesda 10 km north of DC , William A. Zellmer, the Deputy
Executive Vice President of the American Society of Health-System
Pharmacists chaired a meeting of 25 including ex-PSA man Dr Ross
W Holland who now heads PharmEd Consultants.
A number said a survey like the NPDP would be almost possible
to do because privacy laws and the dominance of the non-pharmacy
corporate groups inhibited responses to much of the NPDP questionnaire.
In the afternoon I spoke to the American Pharmacists Association's
executive director William Ellis and Anne Burns the director of
practice development and research.
They showed me 82 impressive APhA publications (www.pharmacist.com
) adding to the 66 produced by the UK's Pharmaceutical Press (
www.pharmpress.com ) and handed me a dozen monographs in the two
continuing education series 'Partners in self-care' and ' The
dynamics of pharmaceutical care' ( Table 2, 2).
Next
day Mitchel Rothholz the APhA's vice president of professional
practice (picture) proudly spoke on the range of pharmacy activities
recognised in the national medical position paper on 'Pharmacist
scope of practice' ( Table 2, 3).
He said over 1,000,000 vaccinations yearly occurred in US pharmacies
especially in the large pharmacy groups now competing for new
professional services and increasingly over the internet with
e-prescribing a reality (Table 2, 4).
US and Canadian national pharmacy authorities have struck an agreement
to oppose internet sales of drugs (see Part 2a) because face-to-face
counselling did not occur and the likely increased risk of adverse
drug effects ( Table 2, 5).
Above:
Mitchel Rothholz APhA vice-president of professional practice
|
The frequent
television and radio advertising ( direct marketing) of pharmaceuticals
we witnessed is known to produce higher pharmaceutical sales but
has little impact on the health of consumers ( Table 2, 6).
That is, these forms of direct marketing drive the public to self-
medication (naming the product) in pharmacies and other outlets
but without appropriate interventions by pharmacists or other
qualified health workers the health outcomes in consumers may
not improve.
We have found in the National Pharmacy Database Project that more
consumers seek advice for their minor health disorders than self-medication
but the ratio of seeking advice to self-medication is higher in
pharmacies in rural and remote than in urban areas.
We fear the frequency of self-medication in Australia's community
pharmacies may soon surpass seeking health advice leaving pharmacists
a declining role in primary health care .
When visiting large US city pharmacies the managing pharmacists
in their inconspicuous dispensaries said consistently they received
around 20-40 health queries each day implying the ratio of health
queries to self-medication was much less than half and probably
less than 1:4.
I concluded the frequency of pharmacist interventions in pharmacy
medicines appears to have fallen so far in large US pharmacies
that pharmacists' role in primary health care there is quickly
becoming trivialised.
This is a poor omen for pharmacy's control of S3 and pharmacy
medicines in other countries .
In Australia
our national pharmacy bodies may need to reconsider the current
emphasis on the processes of pharmacists providing S3 medicines
to comparing the effectiveness of pharmacist- advised actions
(both drugs and others) versus those of self-medication (with
no pharmacist intervention).
In particular , to compare the rates of outcome indicators of
S3 and other non-pharmacy medicines such as reports of misuse,
safety and toxicity to poisons information centres in Australia.
Collating similar data from national registries of poisons centres
in the USA where pharmacist-only medications exist just in Florida
and comparing standardised rates with those from Australia.
Other indicators of drug-related morbidity such as statistics
on OTC drug-related hospital admissions in both countries and
reports to the Drug Abuse Warning Network (DAWN) in the USA need
to be analysed.
Reports from the USA suggest misuse of OTC medications containing
pseudoephedrine and dextromethorphan they have resulted in methods
of or calls for restricting their access in pharmacies and other
outlets (Table 2, 7a and 7b).
Table 1. World pharmacy and medical leaders
in the USA and Canada : 6 - 22 January 2003.
Date |
Place
and theme |
Person/s
and affiliation |
6
January |
Baltimore-
psychotropics in paediatrics; buprenorphine. |
Dr
Julie Zito and Dr T Tommassello, School of Pharmacy, Uni Maryland,
Baltimore |
7 January |
Bethesda
and Washington DC - national survey and pharmacy practice |
William
Zellmer and Dr Ross Holland , Society Health System Pharmacists
Bethesda; Mrs A Burns and Mr W Ellis, APhA, Washington DC
|
8
January |
Washington
DC - pharmacy immunisation, needles |
Michael
C Rothholz , vice president Professional Practice; APhA |
10
January |
New
York City - methadone and buprenorphine |
Mark
Parrino president American Association for the Treatment of
Opioid Dependence , New York |
11
January |
New
York City -nurse |
Sally
Landsberger, Columbia Pharmacy |
13
January |
Toronto
- specialisation |
James
Snowdon, 264 Bloor St, Toronto : Snowdon Pharmacy |
14
January |
Toronto
- ADHD
|
A/Prof
J MacKeigan, A Prof T Einarsson |
17
January |
Los
Angeles- misuse of prescribed drugs |
Prof
W Ling , UCLA Integrated Substance Abuse Program, Los Angeles |
20
January |
San
Francisco |
Paul
B Johnson, pharmacy manager, Walgreen's Pharmacy Fisherman's
Wharf |
21
January |
San
Francisco |
Ruth
Conroy, District Pharmacy Supervisor ,Walgreen's Pharmacies
, San Francisco |
New York City - methadone and pharmacy nurses
On 10th January
I met Mark Parrino the dynamic president of the American Association
for the Treatment of Opioid Dependence Inc (AATOD) and a longtime
advocate of methadone maintenance (MMT) in a country where its
use was pioneered in 1964 but has ironically resisted its use
.
He said there were nearly 1000 accredited methadone treatment
programs in the USA serving around 220,000 patients ( Table 2,
7), about half pro rata Australia's approximately 35,000 MMT patients,
representing 27% increases in both US programs and patients since
December 1998.
Just 1% of US MMT patients are assessed and managed in primary
care.
Community pharmacies became involved on a trial basis in 2001.
AATOD instigated MMT in New York jails in 1987.
Mr Parrino has been a driving force in opening MMT programs in
all but seven States, initiating MMT training programs for 24000
primary care doctors and other practitioners, compiling MMT accreditation
standards, educating Drug Court judges and the public on the benefits
of MMT.
He noted "
Recent oxycodone related admissions to methadone
programs have strained existing resources
"
Mr Parrino blamed much of the 1999-2002 rise in methadone-related
overdose deaths in Maine and Florida on questionable analgesic
prescribing and misclassification of methadone-related deaths
and not on diversion from methadone maintenance programs (Pharmacy
Review April 2003, page 60).
He pointed to methadone deliveries to those States increased by
16% between 2001 and 2002 (DEA ARCOS data.
The majority of this increase was in 5 mg and 10 mg tablets to
pharmacies.
An analysis of prescribing patterns showed a significant number
of primary care doctors have switched from prescribing 'Oxycontin'
to methadone as an analgesic (IMS data,2003) .
The majority of the methadone associated deaths appeared to originate
in doctors in private practice who have no affiliation with methadone
treatment programs.
One of the confounding variables, however, is the fact that no
two medical examiners in the United States would agree on how
to assess a methadone associated death.
There are no standard reporting criteria to follow and many of
the medical examiners do not even agree on the kinds of post-mortem
toxicology tests, which should be used in evaluating methadone
toxicity deaths.
Australia and NSW particularly faced a situation from 1990-2000
when illicit heroin use and methadone peaked and was the highest
in the world.
Forensic scientist Dr Olaf Plummer in Melbourne was the first
to report a spate of methadone induction deaths and was a leader
in characterising methadone-related deaths
Next day I met Sally Landsberger the manager of a small, busy,
six-staff, mainly dispensing community pharmacy filled with Hispanic-
and African- American patients near New York City's Columbia Hospital.
Sally guided me to a separate room used by a nurse engaged to
perform vaccinations, clinical testing for both screening purposes
and monitoring purposes where patients with diabetes, asthma and
cardiovascular diseases were educated in compliance and trained
to use devices for monitoring.
I was impressed by the variety of information printed in Spanish
and other languages to cater for the diverse ethnic minorities.
Chicago
and Toronto - chain store pharmacies
The large group pharmacies visited in Chicago on 13th and 15th
January and other cities days before on the east coast and on
19th to 21st January in San Francisco, typically had large areas
of 200-400 square metres of shelves and modest dispensaries in
the rear or on an upper floor.
Some pharmacy groups in Chicago and other cities engaged either
nurses to regularly rotate amongst their member pharmacies or
they contracted companies with nurses to provide specified services
according to a program.
The most disturbing sight in the group pharmacies was the side-by-side
display of Nicorettes and Nicabate and packets of cigarettes a
practice which has largely but not totally disappeared from Australia's
pharmacies since 1980 !
Some pharmacist managers were embarrassed but helpless to resist
their pharmacy group's corporate commercial-anti-public health
policy or they defended the cigarettes by saying pharmacies were
a trivial supplier in the overall sales of tobacco-containing
products !
On 14th January the University of Toronto's Associate Professor
Linda D. MacKeigan hosted me for a pre-arranged address to a postgraduate
seminar in the Faculty of Pharmacy on our research into psychostimulants.
I spoke to a part-time staff engaged to educate community pharmacists
on the use and misuse of these agents.
Canada is the second highest licit stimulants consumer after the
USA. Frank May and Debra Rowett the leaders of South Australia's
Daw Park Hospital DATIS visit Dr MacKeigan to train 'academic
detailers' for a project aimed at improving prescribing amongst
Ontario's community doctors.
Table
2. Pharmacy themes discussed in USA and Canada in Dec. 2002 -
January 2003
Pharmacy
theme |
Reference
or Publisher |
1.
The medication merry-go-around . (Psychotropics in paediatrics) |
1.
Brown K. Science 2003;299: 1646-9 (14 March 2003) |
2.
Partners in Health-care series : Vol. 3 . Health communications
for culturally diverse patients. Vol. 4. The pharmacist's
role in assuring appropriate OTC medication use. Dynamics
of Pharmaceutical Care series: Monograph 14. Strategies to
improve compensation for pharmacy care services. Monograph
18. Utilizing internet technologies to expand pharmacy-based
patient care services. |
2.
APhA ( American Pharmacists Association) Washington DC, 2002. |
3.
Pharmacist scope of practice. |
3.
ACP-ASIM (American College of Physicians-American Society
of Internal Medicine). Anns Intern Med 2002; 136: 79-85. |
4.
Electronic prescribing : a review of costs and benefits. |
4.
Corley ST. Topics Health Inform Manage 2003; 24: 29-38. |
5.
Pharmacists across North America support call to address Internet
drug sales. May 13, 2003 . |
5.
APhA and CPhA ( American Pharmacists Association and Canadian
Pharmacists Association). accessed 26 May 2003. www.aphanet.org/news/apha_cphastate.htm
, |
6.
Direct marketing of pharmaceuticals to consumers. |
6.
Lyles A. Annu Rev Public Health 2002; 23: 73-91. |
7a.How
R.Ph.s can curb teens' abuse of cough and cold products.
(USA)
7b. Sale of cold pills curbed in drug war. (Missouri,USA)
|
7a.Levy
S. Drug Topics 2002; 146(12): 31.
7b. Associated Press. The West Australian April 15 , 2003
: page 30.
|
8.
The renaissance of methadone treatment in America |
8.
Parrino M. J Maintenance in Addictions 2003; 2(1/2): 5- 17. |
9.
Abuse of prescription opioids |
9.
Ling W, Wesson DR, Smith DE.. In : Graham AW, Schultz TK,
Mayo-Smith MF, Ries RK, Wilford BB. Principles of Addiction
Medicine. Third edition. Chevy Chase (Md): American Society
of Addiction Medicine, 2003. |
10.
Can Wal-Mart get any bigger? ( Yes, a lot bigger
Here's
how). |
10.
Saporito B. Time (Australia). January 13, 2003 : 40-45. |
Los Angeles and San Francisco - licit opioid misuse and Walgreen's
e-pharmacies
On 17th January in Los Angeles I renewed a friendship with Dr
Walter Ling the UCLA's Professor of Psychiatry and head of the
UCLA Integrated Substance Abuse Program .
He spoke on the medical recognition of the diversion, misuse and
abuse of prescribed opioids by both patients , doctors and health
workers in a chapter he had co-authored on 'Abuse of prescription
opioids' (Table 2,8).
This issue has been highlighted nationally in Australia in May
2003 (Tobler H. Theatre of free dreams. The Australian 29 May
2003 : page 15).
The nonmedical use of prescription opioids occurs in over 1.6
million Americans (pro rata over 100,000 Australians) yearly.
Oxycodone -associated deaths jumped from 49 in 1996 to 262 in
1999.
On 20th January in San Francisco I visited a number of group pharmacies
(refer above section under Chicago).
On 21st January I met with Paul B Johnson a pharmacy manager of
Walgreen's Pharmacy Fisherman's Wharf and a 1991 graduate of the
UCSF Faculty of Pharmacy.
Paul managed a typical group pharmacy open from 8am to 9pm in
winter and to midnight in summer (tourist season), consisting
of 2500 sq m area of display shelves and retail counters adjacent
to the entry doors in the control of non-pharmacist staff and
a rear dispensary of similar area to dispensaries in this country.
He dispensed typically 200 items a day and had approximately 30
queries from clients about the treatment of minor ailments .
Neither Paul nor his contemporaries were likely to own their own
pharmacies and he was content to follow a career path in group
pharmacies.
Walgreen's pharmacies were on a website and offered a wide range
of services including health information., prescription ordering,
prescription refill (repeat) prompts , delivery of health equipment
and non-health goods ( www.walgreens.com/pharmacy accessed 31
May 203) .
Doctors could be contacted by email and e-prescribing was planned
to be commence by June 2003.
Paul referred me to Ruth Conroy, District Pharmacy Supervisor
of Walgreen's Pharmacies in San Francisco who I met on 22nd January.
Ruth was a graduate of the School of Pharmacy in the University
of the Pacific at Stockton, 100km east of San Francisco in 1982
.
She supervised over 40 pharmacies from Los Altos 20km south to
San Francisco city.
Ruth ensured pharmacists and non-pharmacist staff attended Walgreen's
external training and conducted in-house training programs according
to Walgreen's requirements.
Walgreen's currently had approximately 3,800 pharmacies in the
group and was aiming within a decade to have 5000 pharmacies -
Australia's total number of pharmacies registered in 2003 with
both State authorities and the Health Insurance Commission !
She thought Wal-Mart the biggest retailer in the USA would become
the biggest group pharmacy by 2020 ( Table 2, 9).
Ruth confirmed the rapid growth of internet sales in the Walgreen
group and predicted pharmacists activities would increasingly
become e-pharmacies for most patient care and health-related activities.
My visit to
the UK, USA and Canada sketched a map of the future of health-related
processes and activities in pharmacies .
Predictions
for community pharmacies to 2020 :
1. Groups of pharmacies will get bigger :
The trend towards membership of pharmacies into groups is undeniable
with 50-55% of Australia's pharmacies already in groups.
This will result in greater efficiencies and increased rivalry
for 'competitive edges' in both commercial and pharmacy practice
activities such as free point-of -care screening in pharmacies.
2. e-pharmacies retain patients and enhance goodwill :
e-pharmacies will develop both as internet information receivers
and internet providers of goods, information and service as part
of pharmacy groups.
e-pharmacy services will reach community-wide into homes and health
care facilities and will help pharmacies better retain patients.
For example, e-pharmacies with existing contracts with residential
aged care facilities or rapidly expanding DMMRs and other types
of medication reviews will be in a better position to retain these
patients and enhance the value of their pharmacies.
3. From S8 dispensing jockeys to S8 online custodians :
The risk of Schedule 8 related misuse amongst children as well
as adults will become so threatening to individual and public
safety and increase medical and pharmacist insurance to such a
degree that legislation will allow internet access by doctors
and pharmacists to State (eg S8) and Commonwealth (eg HIC) -held
patients' drug and medical histories before dispensing hence facilitating
early interventions to prevent misuse .
That is, pharmacists will become online custodians to identify
doctor and pharmacy shopping, forged prescriptions and misuse
of prescribed Schedule 8 drugs and other dependence -producing
agents such as the benzodiazepines.
National and State pharmacy bodies with or without their medical
counterparts will unify for legislation to be enacted to compel
a) privacy release by patients receiving S8 drugs for doctors
and pharmacists to access State and national government-held medication
histories,
b) online access to HIC and State health department medication
data on patients before prescribing and dispensing,
c) online access between dispensers and prescribers before prescribing
or dispensing S8 drugs to suspected misusers and
d) limit S8 sources by patients to one prescriber-one pharmacy
.
4. MediConnect system will be driven by S8 legislation :
MediConnect which has replaced the Better Medication Management
System or BMMS will be driven by the above S8 legislation to overcome
the constraint imposed by patients' 'opt-in' to MediConnect.
To facilitate MediConnect nationally, all medical offices and
pharmacies will require standardised computer hardware, software
and telecommunication (eg ADSL) to facilitate e-prescribing and
the above legislated S8 activities which will extend to S4 and
other schedules of drugs.
Encryption and other computerised security measures will be widely
adopted for e-pharmacy activities
5. Algorithms for S4 to S3 to S2 to
.S100 management :
the above model for S8 drugs will become so efficient and widely
accepted that it will be modified for other schedules of therapeutic
drugs and categories of patients.
Simple standardised health care algorithms for minor to serious
health disorders will facilitate precise selection of S2s , S3s
and better monitoring of S4s.
6. Pharmacies as screening resources :
screening in pharmacies will become recognised as the most efficient
way of increasing new prescriptions for chronic disorders (eg
type 2 diabetes and hypertension) and new profitable non-drug
services for weight reduction will be developed in consultation
either with experts with suitable internet programs and databases
for recording managed overweight clients or in collaboration with
successful weight reduction companies.
A range of efficient screening services will be provided.
Most pharmacies will provide a range of simple non-invasive screening
services from simple anthropometric ( Body Mass Index) , blood
pressure measurement, peak flow meter, bone density screening,
ethanol and pregnancy testing .
More complex invasive testing of fluid specimens for cholesterol
and glucose or immunological tests such as microalbuminuria and
Helicobater pylori will be performed mainly in group pharmacies
which engage nurses.
Additionally, external testing of more complex analytes such as
therapeutic drugs in blood or illicit agents in hair samples will
be sold in security packages as in US pharmacies.
7. Rural pharmacies as nuclear primary health care providers :
large pharmacy groups will replace existing government-funded
health services in many rural and remote areas and develop private
primary health care centres with doctors, nurses and other health
professionals depending on demand.
8. Discharge patients with DAAs transferred to pharmacy care :
first-time and subsequent hospital patients with severe depression
, bipolar and other mental disorders will be discharged with dose
administration aids (DAAs) to the care of designated community
pharmacies .
This will result in markedly improved compliance and lower readmission
rates into high cost hospital beds which will facilitate enhanced
fees for the pharmacies.
9. Client databases, retention of clients and value of pharmacies
:
databases already exist in pharmacy groups in the USA and Australia
with large client membership bases .
By linking point-of-sales with membership numbers they can measure
the effectiveness of commercial promotions , professional innovations
and other types of incentives and the retention of members. Quantitative
markers of numbers of members , retention and POS per member will
become the main determinants of valuing pharmacies.
Ends.
Con
Berbatis
Lecturer
School of Pharmacy
Curtin University of Technology of Western Australia
Chief Investigator
National Community Pharmacy Database Project
3 June, 2003.
berbatis@git.com.au
|